by Kelsie Tan
Man is condemned to be free; because once thrown into the world, he is responsible for everything he does.
Sartre, Being And Nothingness (1943)
We seem to have come to a place where there is a whole lot going on; and yet not much. In our consciousness rests fervent crises that, subsisting on the value of morality, undeniably demands further action; yet I lie in comfort as I type, and you scroll and read these words as we all do. No, yes, indeed we do do more; we grab a tote bag before the door, we skip the straw, we take time to talk about important things. There are some of us that infuse doing more into our purpose in life: those of us committed to sustainable diets, dedicated conservationists, that person who holds a beach clean-up every other day. Yet, it feels like every night we shut our eyes to the world unchanged; its waters seem perpetually tainted with flashy colours, turtles still have straws up their noses and the important things we fervidly talk about never seem to go away. It seems that we all remain small, no matter what we do.
How do we deal with being small? Ideally we do things and change happens, kick a ball and watch it fly, but here we kick balls on a daily basis only to see them move not close to an inch. Just a stubbed toe for show. Maybe it’s because this ball is the size of our universe, and made up of fluctuating temperatures, volatile gases, polar ideologies and big, unshifting systems. A ball made of cold metal and drilled to the ground. To this unshifting obstacle one can take several courses of actions. One can choose to sit and stare into space, since the ball is inherently immovable. One can sit but contemplate how to go about moving the ball, despite knowing that the ball is steadfastly stuck. One can spend their days and nights actually pushing the thing, and celebrating a microscopic shift, before the ball rolls back into place. The path ahead remains untrodden. How will you live in today’s world?
We are, I am, you are
by cowardice or courage
the one who find our way
back to this scene
carrying a knife, a camera
a book of myths
in which
our names do not appear.
Adrienne Rich, “Diving into the Wreck” (1973)
I feel that the extent to which one can kick the ball is very dependant on the situation that we are in. For instance, governments and NGOs can kick the ball of climate change further than we can as students. (I am in no way undermining the efforts of students fighting for the cause, because it is heartening that they are doing their best to kick that ball.) In my case, I feel that the best way I can contribute is to level myself up and put myself in a position that’s able to effect greater change.
P.s: your piece is really beautiful!
LikeLike
It really is difficult to know about all these issues that plague the world on a daily basis, and feel like we can’t do anything about it. But I remain steadfast on my opinion that little things matter. Many people taking small steps to make more eco-conscious decisions, for example, can make a huge difference when the effects are compounded. The biggest changes happen when society as a whole makes better decisions, and it starts with people deciding to try. I had an incredible opportunity to meet Dr Sylvia Earle, renowned oceanographer (she is so amazing), the other day, and she talked to us about many things, including how changes we make in our diet, for instance, can make a difference to what’s happening in the oceans. So I guess what I’m trying to say is that, we should all try to kick the ball, because we are not Sisyphus – condemned to push a boulder that will always roll back down. The difference between us and Sisyphus is that we CAN make a difference, as long as we do not become indifferent.
LikeLike
I also find myself quite often thinking that many of the stuff that one can do to change today’s world is just useless. As sad as it is, what a group of individuals can do for, for instance, the environment, is insignificant when compared to a big company’s smallest change in policies.
What is in fact in our hands, however, is to simply be more demanding when it comes to these companies. Raising awareness of topics is obviously not useless, and by doing so we are pushing them to improve their outlook and thus their actions.
LikeLike
I do believe that the individual in society is often faced with an age-old dilemma when it comes to making changes to improve our world for the better. More often than not, we are faced with immense negativity from the majority who prefer to remain within the confines of the status quo and continue to live without thinking too hard on the ‘what-if’s. Even if they are supportive of positive change, they rarely step up to effect any concrete action. There are a multitude of factors that influence such thinking; cultural, societal, institutional, political… and the list goes on. The inherent risk is that those who are brave enough to take action could be influenced to become apathetic and lose interest in ‘kicking the ball’.
However, I think we should persevere to champion noble causes that will help society to prosper and improve the deteriorating condition of our planet and people. One way we could approach these issues is to utilise channels that will help us to reach those who have the power and authority to effect change. This is known as the Stakeholder Approach. By understanding the needs and influence of organisations, one is able to garner support to fix social issues and bring about a comprehensive answer to the question of futility of action.
Nonetheless, I do acknowledge that not everyone will have the opportunity or be in a position to implement such theoretical frameworks into their line of work/area of interest. To the individual, I say that we ought to try (at the very least) to seek out like minded-individuals and tackle the issues plaguing our world. As the saying goes, there is always Unity in Strength!
LikeLike
It is true that even if an individual does not use plastic straws, does not drive cars, uses reusable bags and bottles, and does everything that is ecofriendly, the significance of these actions will still be insignificant. However, if every individual makes the slightest effort to do something, the significance will be much larger.
There was once a time people do not harm the environment as they simply do not have the ability to do so, the main problem that people prioritize solving then was low efficiency and inconvenience. Then people invented lots of technologies to solve that problem, however, these technologies served as a double edge sword, it slowly harmed the environment. Now, our main concern and priority should be the environment. So people again invented new technologies that do not harm the environment. And as these ”harmless” technology become increasingly popular and more widely used, I believe the problem on environments will be alleviated. This, however, is under the premise that people, as a whole population and not as an individual, are concerned.
LikeLike
Hi Kelsie, this is such a beautiful post! Although quite nihlistic, I think it’s true that we feel helpless and that lots of our attempts to initiate change feel futile and ineffective. If you look to history, it feels somewhat inevitable that we will remain passive to wider environmental changes and wider structural and societal changes. I guess to deal with these feelings of helplessness, all we can do is try to make change in the smaller aspects of our lives and find purpose within our day-to-day lives. Maybe this is why people may feel apathetic towards ‘big issues’, and you can’t really blame them.
LikeLike
Seeking changes with regards to social or environmental issues are quite tricky to trace out, whether it’s 1 year or 15 years of time span. We can refer to statistics and look at the numbers and make a comparison over time period, which is helpful and makes us more analytical – but even statistics can lie.
With regards to several posts regarding every action matters, like what others have mentioned that it is actually quite true. It is not so much about what people do on a large end scale, the commitment to reduce any acts such as reducing plastic bag usage and straws are something, are little actions but they add up to something bigger. Talking about this to your friends or family members about matters important to you (and to them) is also something that we should not underestimate. Unfortunately, quite often many take it for granted.
This is similar to the concept of marketing and advertising, you will see how effective and influential they are, simply based on numbers over a time frame period.
LikeLike
It’s funny, I’ve read community organizers and activists marching and striking and doing workshops spreading their stance on world, building solidarity with one another while ranting about how they feel small and not being able to affect the world at large. So I think this sense of hopelessness and meaningless is in the end a malaise from individualistic projection, gazing the world through its endlessly limited lens. Action, meaning, effect, it’s always been there, we’re just trained to gloss over it if it the solution to an issue can’t be atomized to “how can this improve my standing in the world” even as some would say that “the world” is a structure with defects that can be improved upon, or dismantled entirely to create a new one that better serves our needs.
LikeLike
Wonderful piece! I can definitely relate to the feeling of insignificance when it comes to my own contribution towards solving major global issues. Yet, I do still believe that individual action is important, not just to directly address the environmental and socio-economic issues that plague our society, but also to bring about a change in mindset. Of course, the actions of an individual can’t compare in scale and consequence to those made by multinational corporations acting in the interest of maximising profits for their shareholders. But, these companies make their profits by catering to society. If the public opinion is overwhelmingly against exploitative practices, then the large companies will have to correct their stance.
It’s also important to remember that CEOs and shareholders are also people, just like us. And while the current generation may be willing to sacrifice environmental protection for monetary gain, a change in mindset can help ensure that the next generation of CEOs and shareholders are a little less selfish.
So, while little acts such as carrying my own bag or skipping a straw don’t contribute much, they are important to get a conversation going with my peers which eventually leads to a greater societal change.
Or at least, I like to think so to make myself feel better.
LikeLike
This is so beautifully written!!
I think no matter how despairing and futile it can feel when trying to move a big rock, it’s important to remember all the small changes we make. Every straw we don’t use is a straw that won’t make it to the ocean, every time you don’t eat meat that’s one less animal suffering. Every little action has a result, sometimes small, even microscopic but no change is insignificant.
I love the Sartre quote in the beginning because instead of despairing it seems to me to be a call for action. When existentialism first began to get traction it was often presumed to be something ugly, or nihilistic; instead, Sartre claims that it’s humanism. “Man simply is. Not that he is simply what he conceives himself to be, but he is what he wills, and as he conceives himself after already existing – as he wills to be after that leap towards existence. Man is nothing else but that which he makes of himself. ” It certainly is tempting to look at this great big mess we have in front of us, and decide it isn’t worth the uphill battle, but that is a choice we actively make, and that is a choice that defines us. It is what you do that makes you who you are
While we are entirely responsible for our lives, and our actions, we are also free to make choices and take action. We are free to define ourselves, and that is what distinguishes us from Sisyphus. Our boulders are big and are many, but unlike Sisyphus when we finally push the boulder up the hill at the end of the day, there’s no saying that it will roll back down.
Existentialism is a Humanism
https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/sartre/works/exist/sartre.htm
LikeLike
I never thought I’d see Marx here =D
LikeLike